The only downside would be that the Super Magnum does excess weight an additional 1/2 pound, and you will only obtain a 28'' barrel on it, but it's nonetheless a lightweight contour barrel. I just got the Super Mag at the time because I assumed the downside wasn't that good, https://academy-sports-remington10987.theisblog.com/34826272/5-easy-facts-about-remington-870-fieldmaster-for-sale-described